Skip to content



Compare Prescription Drug Plans

Compare prescription drug plans alongside BasiCare Plus, one of the nation's top drug plans with no Medicare/Medicaid requirements. All plans have $0 copay and $0 deductibles.

Navigating Medicare plans to compare prescription drug plans is essential as Medicare Part D plans cover prescription drugs for beneficiaries, highlighting the importance of making informed decisions about Medicare prescription plans 2. The United States government’s official website provides a crucial resource for beneficiaries to log in and review their current coverage, further facilitating a comprehensive medicare plans comparison 1.

With an average of nearly 60 options for Part D coverage available in 2024, the landscape of Medicare Part D coverage is becoming increasingly complex, underscoring the necessity for a detailed medicare plans comparison to ensure optimal drug coverage 3. This dynamic environment makes it imperative for beneficiaries to closely compare drug plans, keeping abreast of changes and ensuring their chosen plan continues to meet their needs 3.

Plan Coverage and Formulary

Overview of Changes and Formulary Options

Medicare Part D Plans: Key Changes in Coverage

  1. In 2024, Medicare Part D plans have introduced several significant changes including a higher deductible, an increased initial coverage limit, and a higher out-of-pocket spending threshold 5.
  2. All insulins under Medicare Part D will be capped at $35 for a month’s supply, reflecting a concerted effort to manage costs for beneficiaries 5.
  3. Notably, plans have the authority to alter drug coverage by discontinuing medications, modifying medication tiers, or imposing new restrictions 5.

Formulary Insights and Plan Options

  • A majority of non-SNP MAPD plans (94%) will include insulins on the preferred brand formulary tier, maintaining the $35 maximum copay in 2024 4.
  • The average Medicare beneficiary has the option to choose from approximately 59 Medicare plans that include Part D drug coverage, though the total number of Prescription Drug Plans (PDPs) and firms offering these plans has seen a decline from the previous year 3.
  • Enrollees must be aware that most PDP enrollees will experience significantly higher cost-sharing for brand-name drugs compared to generic drugs in 2024 3.

Annual Notifications and Regulatory Caps

  • Plans are mandated to issue an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) to enrollees, which details any significant changes in coverage and costs for the upcoming year 5.
  • The Inflation Reduction Act plays a crucial role by continuing to cap out-of-pocket costs for insulins at $35 and by limiting the growth in the base beneficiary premium to a 6% annual increase 6.
  • Furthermore, the Act stipulates that Part D plans must not apply the deductible to any covered insulin product and must limit charges to no more than $35 per month during both the initial coverage and the coverage gap phases 7.

Availability and Choice Across States

  • Beneficiaries in each state have multiple PDP options ranging from 15 in New York to 24 in Alabama and Tennessee, alongside various Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug plans (MA-PDs) available at the local level 3.
  • It’s important for beneficiaries, especially those receiving Part D Low-Income Subsidies (LIS), to note that the number of benchmark PDPs available in 2024 has decreased, necessitating potential plan switches during the open enrollment period to maintain enrollment in a benchmark plan 3.

This detailed overview of the changes, options, and regulatory implications provides a comprehensive understanding of the evolving landscape of Medicare Part D coverage and the formulary options available to beneficiaries in 2024.

Cost Analysis

Premium Trends and Legislative Caps

Premium Adjustments

  1. The average total monthly Part D premium is projected to decrease slightly from $56.49 in 2023 to $55.50 in 2024, reflecting a modest reduction in costs for beneficiaries 6.
  2. Despite the general decrease, specific states will see significant premium increases, with hikes ranging between 42% and 57% in the five states with the largest populations of Medicare beneficiaries over 65 8.

Impact of the Inflation Reduction Act

  • The Inflation Reduction Act caps the annual increase in the base beneficiary premium to no more than 6% starting from 2024, aiming to stabilize the financial burden on enrollees 6 14.
  • This Act also introduces a $2,000 out-of-pocket cap for Part D prescription drugs starting in 2025, significantly reducing the maximum drug costs for seniors compared to over $7,000 in 2023 6 8.

Out-of-Pocket Cost Management

Reductions and Caps

  1. The IRA eliminates cost-sharing for recommended adult vaccines and limits cost-sharing for covered insulin products starting in 2024 6.
  2. Beneficiaries entering the catastrophic phase of coverage in 2024 will not have to pay for their prescription drugs for the remainder of the year, easing the financial burden during high-need periods 15.

Support Programs

  • The Low-Income Subsidy (LIS) and the Limited Income Newly Eligible Transition (LI NET) program will offer enhanced support, reducing out-of-pocket costs for eligible individuals and making the program permanent, respectively 13 14.
  • These changes are designed to help those with high drug costs manage expenses more predictably across the year 11 14.

Plan Variability and Choice

Plan Options and Changes

  • The average Medicare beneficiary has a choice of 59 Medicare plans with Part D drug coverage, though the total number of Prescription Drug Plans (PDPs) has decreased from 801 in 2023 to 709 in 2024 3.
  • Monthly premiums for drug coverage are substantially higher for PDPs compared to Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug plans (MA-PDs), with PDPs being five times higher on average 3.

Strategic Enrollment Decisions

  • Beneficiaries affected by plan changes can switch plans during Medicare’s open enrollment period, ensuring they continue to receive coverage for the prescription drugs they need 9.

Pharmacy and Network Considerations

Network Size and Accessibility

1. Extensive Pharmacy Networks

Medicare Part D plans typically offer extensive pharmacy networks, which include both national chains and local pharmacies to ensure that beneficiaries have accessible prescription drug services across different locations 10.

2. Preferred vs. Standard Pharmacy Pricing

Many plans differentiate between preferred and standard pharmacies, offering lower co-pays at preferred locations. This pricing structure encourages beneficiaries to choose specific pharmacies to maximize their savings on prescription drugs 10.

3. Impact of Network Restrictions

Restrictions within pharmacy networks can impact beneficiaries, particularly those in rural areas where pharmacy choices are limited. It’s crucial for beneficiaries to verify whether their preferred pharmacy is included in a plan’s network to avoid higher out-of-pocket costs 10.

Mail Order Services

Advantages of Using Mail Order Pharmacies

  1. Cost Efficiency: Mail order pharmacies often provide medications at a lower cost, especially for long-term prescriptions, which can be crucial for budget management in seniors 11.
  2. Convenience: They offer the convenience of home delivery, which is particularly beneficial for those with mobility issues or those who reside in remote areas 11.

Considerations for Mail Order Services

  • While mail order is advantageous, it’s important to consider potential delays in delivery which could affect how timely a beneficiary receives their medication. Ensuring that there is adequate planning and communication with the provider is essential to mitigate these risks 11.

Impact of Pharmacy Choice on Drug Availability

Drug Formulary Variations Across Pharmacies

Different pharmacies may have varying stock levels or availability of certain medications due to their agreements with manufacturers. Beneficiaries need to confirm the availability of their prescriptions in their chosen pharmacy to ensure uninterrupted treatment 12.

Specialty Medications and Pharmacy Selection

Specialty pharmacies are often necessary for handling complex medications that require specific storage or handling conditions. Beneficiaries using specialty medications should ensure their plan’s network includes a pharmacy capable of providing these services 12.

Member Satisfaction and Plan Performance

Star Ratings Overview

Understanding the Impact of Star Ratings

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) utilizes a Star Ratings system to evaluate the performance and quality of Medicare Advantage (MA) and Prescription Drug Plans (PDPs). These ratings, published annually, serve as a crucial tool for beneficiaries to compare and select plans based on quality 16.

2024 Star Ratings Insights

For the year 2024, the Star Ratings have incorporated methodological changes such as Tukey outlier deletion to enhance the predictability and stability of these ratings. This adjustment affects all non-Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS) measures 16.

Performance Metrics and Beneficiary Impact

High Performing Plans

In 2024, approximately 42% of MA-PD contracts received an overall rating of 4 stars or higher. When weighted by enrollment, this statistic reveals that about 74% of MA-PD enrollees are in plans rated 4 stars or above, indicating a significant portion of beneficiaries are covered by high-quality plans 16.

Plans with Low Performance

Conversely, there are six contracts marked with a low performing icon on the Medicare Plan Finder for 2024, highlighting plans that have consistently received low quality ratings 16.

Organizational Influence on Ratings

Non-Profit vs. For-Profit

Data indicates that non-profit organizations tend to secure higher Star Ratings more frequently compared to for-profit organizations. This trend suggests that non-profit plans may offer better service quality or beneficiary satisfaction 16.

Detailed Analysis of Plan Ratings

Distribution of Star Ratings

The distribution of Star Ratings for 2024 shows a notable number of contracts achieving high ratings, with 36 contracts earning a 5-star rating, showcasing exceptional performance and service quality 16.

Plan Experience and Ratings

Analysis reveals that contracts with more experience in the MA program are more likely to achieve higher overall Star Ratings. This correlation underscores the value of established programs in delivering quality healthcare services 16.

Humana’s Performance in Star Ratings

Humana’s High Ratings

Humana Inc. has demonstrated strong performance with nearly 94% of its Medicare Advantage members enrolled in plans rated 4 stars and above for 2024. Additionally, Humana received a 5 out of 5-star rating for four of its contracts, covering around 790,000 members 17.

Nationwide Coverage

Humana offers Medicare Advantage plans rated 4 stars and above across all 50 states and Puerto Rico, ensuring a wide-reaching impact on Medicare beneficiaries seeking quality plans 17.


Throughout the discourse on comparing prescription drug plans in 2024, we’ve uncovered a landscape marked by significant changes and varying options available to Medicare beneficiaries. From the notable shifts in Part D plan coverage, such as the cap on insulin prices, to the intricacies of plan formularies and the strategic decisions needed during open enrollment periods, the information provided aims to guide beneficiaries in navigating this complex terrain. This analysis highlights the importance of meticulous plan comparison, emphasizing the potential for cost savings and optimized coverage in light of legislative developments and market dynamics.

The implications of these findings extend beyond individual choices, touching on broader themes of healthcare accessibility and affordability. As the Medicare landscape continues to evolve, driven by policy changes and market forces, the value of informed decision-making cannot be overstated. Beneficiaries are encouraged to leverage the insights gained to ensure their selections align with their healthcare needs and financial considerations. Ultimately, the discussions underscore the pivotal role of comprehensive, up-to-date information in empowering Medicare participants to make choices that enhance their wellbeing and financial security in the year ahead.


What is the top-rated Part D prescription plan for 2024?

Finding the best Part D plan depends on individual needs and medications. It’s recommended to review and compare plans based on coverage specifics and out-of-pocket costs.

What are the details of Prescription Drug Plans (PDPs) for 2024?

In 2024, of the 14 national PDPs, 9 will offer $0 copays for preferred generics. However, copays for preferred brand drugs will range from $40 to $47, or a coinsurance of 16% to 25%. For non-preferred drugs, coinsurance will vary between 39% and 50%, with 6 of the 14 plans charging the maximum of 50%.

What are the Medicare Part B premiums and deductibles for 2024?

The standard monthly premium for Medicare Part B in 2024 will be $174.70, up from $164.90 in 2023. The annual deductible for all Medicare Part B enrollees will be $240, which is an increase of $14 from the previous year.

Which Medicare Advantage plan is considered the best for 2024?

Humana is highly recommended as the best Medicare Advantage plan for most people in 2024. It stands out due to its broad selection of no-cost monthly plans, excellent prescription benefits, high-quality ratings, and strong customer service.


[1] –
[2] –
[3] –
[4] –
[5] –
[6] –
[7] –
[8] –
[9] –
[10] –
[11] –
[12] –
[13] –
[14] –
[15] –
[16] –
[17] –