Skip to content


Gig economy

Key Factors to Consider When Comparing Prescription Drug Plans

Comparing prescription drug plans? Need stand-alone prescription drug coverage ASAP? It is now possible with BasiCare Plus. Get covered online in 3 minutes. No medical questions and guaranteed acceptance. Includes a free primary care provider.

Selecting the right Medicare drug plan requires navigating a complex landscape of prescription drug coverage, especially as Original Medicare Parts A and B typically exclude prescriptions unless associated with a hospital stay. The availability of Medicare Part D from private insurers allows beneficiaries to compare prescription drug plans, tailoring their choice to best suit their healthcare needs and budgetary considerations.

With over 50 million people enrolled in Part D plans in 2023, understanding the nuances of coverage, including formularies, costs, and pharmacy networks becomes paramount. This article aims to simplify the process, providing key insights on how to compare prescription drug plans effectively, factoring in coverage options, cost implications, network restrictions, and enrollment guidelines.

Coverage and Drug Formularies

When comparing prescription drug plans, it’s crucial to delve into the specifics of coverage and drug formularies to ensure your medications are covered and affordable. Here’s a breakdown to guide your comparison:

  • Formulary and Coverage Gap:
    • Ensure your medications are listed in the plan’s formulary.
    • Some plans offer coverage in the coverage gap; verify if your drugs are covered during this phase.
    • Plans with no or a low deductible, or additional coverage in the gap, can offer significant savings.
  • Costs for Generic vs. Brand-name Drugs:
    • If you frequently use generic prescriptions, seek plans with low copayments for these medications.
    • Medicare mandates coverage for a broad spectrum of drugs, including most in protected classes, addressing conditions like opioid use disorders.
  • Plan Flexibility and Support:
    • Be aware that formularies can change; plans should notify you of any alterations affecting your prescriptions.
    • Explore benefits like the new insulin cap at $35 for a one-month supply, highlighting plans adapting to policy changes for better affordability.

Utilizing tools like the Medicare Prescription Drug Plan Finder can simplify finding plans that align with your needs, including the Formulary Finder for state-specific plan comparisons. Moreover, programs like LIS offer full benefits, ensuring support for those eligible under the Inflation Reduction Act, underscoring the importance of comprehensive plan evaluation.

Cost Analysis

Understanding the financial implications of different Medicare drug plans is crucial. Here’s a breakdown of costs to consider when comparing prescription drug plans:

  • Premiums, Deductibles, and Copayments/Coinsurance:
    • Premiums are monthly fees for coverage. The 2024 Part D base beneficiary premium is $34.70, with a cap on annual growth at 6%.
    • Deductibles are out-of-pocket costs before insurance kicks in. In 2023, the standard deductible for PDPs is $505, while MA-PDs have an average drug deductible of $58.
    • Copayments/Coinsurance are payments for each prescription after meeting the deductible. Plans may have tiered cost structures affecting these costs.
  • The Coverage Gap and Out-of-Pocket Maximums:
    • After reaching a spending threshold ($4,350 in 2009, $4,550 in 2010), enrollees hit the coverage gap, paying all drug costs until reaching the out-of-pocket maximum.
    • The ACA sets out-of-pocket maximums ($8,550 for individuals in 2021), limiting total expenditure.
  • Plan-Specific Costs and Assistance Programs:
    • Monthly premiums vary widely, from $0 to nearly $200, depending on the plan and location.
    • High-income enrollees may face an income-related surcharge, adding $12.90 to $81.00 to monthly costs.
    • The Low-Income Subsidy (LIS) program offers premium and cost-sharing assistance to eligible enrollees, significantly reducing out-of-pocket expenses.

When comparing prescription drug plans, consider these cost elements alongside your medication needs and financial situation to find a plan that offers the best value.

Networks and Pharmacies

When comparing prescription drug plans, a critical aspect to consider is the network of pharmacies each plan includes. Medicare Part D plans categorize pharmacies into three types:

  • Preferred in-network pharmacies: These pharmacies have agreements with the insurance plan to offer prescriptions at the lowest cost-sharing amount. They are the most economical option for plan members.
  • Standard in-network pharmacies: While still within the network, these pharmacies have a slightly higher cost-sharing amount for prescriptions compared to preferred in-network pharmacies.
  • Out-of-network pharmacies: These pharmacies do not have any negotiated pricing or discounts with the insurance plan, leading to higher out-of-pocket costs for prescriptions.

It’s also important to note that pharmacy networks can change from year to year, so it’s essential to verify whether your preferred pharmacy is included in a plan’s network for the upcoming year. For instance, UnitedHealthcare offers four different Medicare Part D prescription drug plans, each with its own service area, annual deductible, drug list, and preferred retail network. This diversity allows beneficiaries to choose a plan that best fits their needs, emphasizing the importance of understanding and comparing the pharmacy networks when selecting a prescription drug plan.

Enrollment Periods and Eligibility

Navigating the enrollment periods and understanding eligibility criteria are crucial steps in selecting a Medicare Part D plan that aligns with your prescription drug needs and financial situation. Here’s a breakdown to assist in your decision-making process:

  • Enrollment Periods:
    • Initial Enrollment Period (IEP): Starts 3 months before and ends 3 months after the month you turn 65.
    • Medicare Annual Election Period (AEP): Oct. 15 to Dec. 7 each year for reviewing and changing your plan.
    • Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (OEP): Jan. 1 to March 31 annually for switching between plans.
    • Special Enrollment Period (SEP): Available during certain life events for plan changes.
  • Eligibility:
    • Must be eligible for Medicare Part A and/or Part B.
    • Can enroll or switch plans during IEP, AEP, or SEP.
    • Eligibility for Extra Help or Medicaid allows for any-time plan changes.
  • Considerations:
    • Review prescription drug needs annually in the fall.
    • Check the plan’s star rating for quality assessment.
    • Understand plan restrictions like prior authorization or step therapy.

This structured approach ensures you are well-informed about the timing and criteria for enrolling in or switching Medicare Part D plans, facilitating a choice that best suits your healthcare and financial needs.


How can I evaluate different Part D prescription drug plans?

To assess and compare various stand-alone Part D plans or Medicare Advantage Plans that include drug coverage, you can use the Medicare Plan Finder. This online tool is available at and provides detailed information about the costs associated with each plan, the specific drugs covered under the plan’s formulary, and the plan’s overall star rating.

What criteria should I consider to determine the most suitable Medicare plan for my needs?

When selecting a Medicare plan, you should consider several important factors:

  • The overall cost of coverage, including premiums and out-of-pocket expenses.
  • Any additional benefits offered by the plan, such as vision, hearing, and travel coverage.
  • The extent of Medicare Part D coverage for your prescription medications.
  • Whether you can continue seeing your current healthcare provider or if you will need to switch.
  • The availability of extra perks, such as gym memberships and other value-added services.

What causes the price variation among different Medicare Part D plans?

The reason why some Medicare Part D plans are significantly less expensive than others is often due to the tiered formulary system they use. Medications are categorized into different price tiers, with copayments or coinsurance costs typically being lower for drugs in the lower tiers. As you move to higher tiers, which usually include brand-name or specialty drugs, the associated costs increase.

On what basis are drug tiers for prescription plans established?

Prescription drug tiers are determined by the cost of the medication. Each plan’s formulary is divided into levels known as “tiers.” The copayment or coinsurance you are required to pay when you fill a prescription is contingent on which tier the medication falls into, with lower-cost drugs typically placed in the lower tiers and higher-cost drugs in the upper tiers.